Updated Technology More Crucial than Hospital Quality for Prostate Cancer Patients, U.K. Study Finds

Updated Technology More Crucial than Hospital Quality for Prostate Cancer Patients, U.K. Study Finds
Men with prostate cancer patients may choose where to have surgery based on the availability of new technology over what they know about the quality of the hospital itself, a British study finds. The hospital's reputation and its doctors also influence the decision-making process, concludes the report, “Effect of patient choice and hospital competition on service configuration and technology adoption within cancer surgery: a national, population-based study,” which appeared The Lancet Oncology. “It appears that patients use the availability of robotic prostatectomy as an indicator of high quality care, despite a lack of evidence of its superiority compared with open surgery," Ajay Aggarwal, the study's lead author, said in a press release. "NHS [National Health Service] hospitals are investing millions of pounds into new and sometimes unproven technologies which have a direct impact on the type of care patients receive.” The authors’ assessment is that competition among hospitals — in addition to policies promoting centralization and the requirement to do minimum numbers of surgical procedures — have consequently increased investment in equipment for robotic surgery, even without any evidence of superior outcomes. But if men don't have access to quality performance and outcome indic
Subscribe or to access all post and page content.


  1. Lawrence Glickman says:

    There is simply no evidence of surgery in general being superior to other less invasive treatments for patients with organ confined lesions and PSA less than 6 and Gleeson score 6 combined or less. Yet Doctors continue to sell the Da Vinci surgery to all as the ‘Gold Standard’. There are many new techniques and but few up to date oncologists and almost zero surgeons who are familiar with other options. This is sad and possibly predatory as it seems that the most profitable options for the Doctor get the most attention.

  2. Stephen B. Strum, MD, FACP says:

    Talking to men and their significant others in my subspecialty of prostate cancer over the course of 35 years has led me to conclude somewhat differently then what the title of your News Today item says (i.e., “Updated technology more crucial….”

    Most patients & spouses make decisions based on media advertising rather than on the issue of advanced technology per se. In the USA we are flooded with TV advertisements re drugs and medical facilities– these influence peoples’ decisions. Also, patients are enamored about the name of a center and are more influenced by the “edifice” then the individual healthcare practitioner’s expertise. I have termed this an “edifice complex” and it is definitely operative in the world of medicine, including oncology. Patients say “I went to MD Anderson” rather than I saw Chris Logothetis at MD Anderson. In my opinion, patients lack the sophistication to realize that there is a range of expertise in all aspects of life, including physicians. It’s the bell-shaped curve & that “curve” appears to be shifting to the left.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *